Why the Smartest Companies Stopped Renting Their Insurance
Companies often begin owning their insurance out of necessity. They keep doing it because it pays. That pattern is now reaching cannabis.
NEW YORK — Harvard’s hospitals started insuring themselves in 1976 to survive a malpractice crisis. The crisis passed. The hospitals kept their insurer. Half a century later it covers thirty-two hospitals and some eighteen thousand physicians, and it shows no sign of closing.
The pattern—an insurer formed in an emergency and kept by choice—recurs across industries. It explains why companies keep buying into the idea even when commercial insurance gets cheaper.
A telling statistic
Marsh’s captive benchmarking research describes owners reviewing and expanding their existing structures. A mature captive may add coverage as its business and risk profile change, rather than remain limited to the risks it first insured.
Why owners stay
Owners keep eligible underwriting surplus after claims, operating expenses, reinsurance and required reserves.
Their safety spending pays them back. Every claim prevented lowers their own costs, not a carrier’s.
They gain control. Owners decide what to insure, who handles claims, and how reserves are invested. The renewal notice stops dictating the budget.
The value compounds. Reserves and surplus grow year after year, alongside coverage tailored to the business. Those reserves are invested, and the investment income they earn belongs to the owners too.

Cannabis: early, and moving
Cannabis has been slow to follow, for understandable reasons. Many operators don’t know the option exists. Capital is costly. Many companies are young, run a single store, or do not have sufficient revenue. And cannabis scheduling long muted the tax advantages. Those obstacles are falling. Dedicated programs have appeared, such as 3F Captive Services’ offering. And for medical operators whose activity is covered by April’s rescheduling order, premiums paid to a properly built captive can now be deductible, which restores much of the tax case that 280E took away.
The legal ground is firmer, too. Courts have upheld captives that function as genuine insurance and rejected those built on inflated premiums and improbable risks. The path is clearly marked: independent actuarial pricing, real risk, real claims, experienced counsel.

Who should look now
For multistate, vertically integrated, and established single-state cannabis operators—medical operators above all—the conditions that pushed hospitals and truckers to own their insurance are present: high prices, thin coverage, and risks the market won’t write.
The first step is to total three years of premiums and uninsured losses. 3F Captive Services offers a complimentary policy analysis that reviews existing policies against actual exposures and shows whether a captive insurance program is an appropriate fit for a specific business. If it is, a feasibility study follows, where the captive’s policies are designed and priced.

By Patrick Johnston, Co-Founder, 3F Captive Services
Patrick Johnston is co-founder of 3F Captive Services, which helps mid-sized businesses form and manage captive insurance companies. He has spent more than twenty years running and investing in businesses: he operated a dairy, has owned S&P Ranch, LLC, a California specialty-crop grower, since 2008, and has been chief executive of AgCentra Capital Management since 2016. He co-founded 3F in 2022 and works with owners in agriculture, cannabis, transportation and logistics, construction, health care, hospitality, and professional services. He holds a B.A. in economics from the University of Washington and an M.B.A. from Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management.
This is sponsored content. It was written by Patrick Johnston of 3F Captive Services and published by HCN in partnership with 3F Captive Services. It is for general information only and is not insurance, tax, or legal advice. Readers should consult their own qualified advisers.






































