The Tax That Makes Insurance Cost Twice

4.6 min readPublished On: November 19th, 2026By

For years, Section 280E turned cannabis insurance into a double expense. April’s rescheduling changed the math for medical operators, and opened a way for every operator to keep more of its premium dollars.

NEW YORK — For more than a decade, cannabis companies paid for insurance twice. First came premiums that specialists say can run two or three times those of comparable businesses. Then came Section 280E of the tax code, which forbids any business trafficking in a Schedule I or II substance to deduct ordinary expenses. The premiums could not be written off.

Here is what that difference can look like for two companies of similar size, one conventional and one cannabis. The figures are illustrative, not market quotes. Imagine a conventional company that pays $60,000 a year in premiums and deducts them; at the 21-percent federal corporate rate, that saves $12,600, so the real cost is $47,400. The cannabis operator, subject to Section 280E, pays an assumed $200,000 and can deduct nothing, so the real cost is the full $200,000. That is more than four times as much for comparable coverage. (Actual results depend on entity type, state taxes and each company’s tax position.)

What changed in April

The April 2026 medical-marijuana order changed the treatment of covered activity. The Treasury subsequently announced plans for tax guidance, including expense allocation for businesses with multiple activities. Holding a state medical license should not be treated as a blanket guarantee that every expense is deductible.

The medical order did not provide equivalent relief for adult-use activity. Mixed businesses should establish how expenses relate to covered and uncovered operations with their tax advisers.

The medical operator’s opening

For medical operators, this change does more than restore a deduction. It opens a strategy that companies in other industries have used for decades: owning a share of their own insurance.

Here is how it works. A medical operator whose activity is covered by the April order can deduct the premiums it pays to a captive it owns, as long as the captive is genuine insurance: it takes on real risk, spreads that risk, charges premiums an independent actuary can support, and pays real claims. A small captive can also elect under Section 831(b), which for 2026 is open to captives writing up to $2.9 million a year in premiums, subject to further eligibility conditions. Under that election, the captive pays tax on its investment income, not on the premiums it collects. The result: the operator deducts the premium, the captive is not taxed on it, and whatever is not needed for claims stays in a company the operator owns.

The IRS scrutinizes these arrangements, and courts have rejected captives that were not real insurance, so the structure has to be built properly from the start, with specialist review of reporting obligations and current litigation.

The adult-use operator’s opening

Adult-use operators cannot deduct premiums, whether paid to a carrier or to a captive. But the choice still matters, because it decides where the money ends up. A premium paid to a commercial carrier is gone. A premium paid to a captive, less claims and expenses, stays with the owners as reserves.

For a company spending $200,000 a year on insurance it cannot deduct either way, keeping the unused share rather than surrendering it is no small sum.

The other half of the tax story sits inside the captive. A small captive that elects under Section 831(b) pays tax on its investment income, not on the premiums it receives, whether its owner is a medical or an adult-use operator. So the money an adult-use operator could not deduct is not taxed a second time when it reaches the captive. And if broader rescheduling takes effect, the operator’s premiums become deductible like any other insurance expense, with reserves already built.

Building it to last

The tax analysis starts with real insurance: genuine risk transfer and distribution, commercially supportable premiums, appropriate capital and actual insurance operations. An independent actuary and experienced counsel should test the structure. A captive sold as an automatic way around Section 280E is not a sound basis for planning.

The number to run

Start with the true economic cost of the current insurance program: premiums plus uninsured losses, adjusted for what is deductible under the company’s licenses. Then model the same costs with a captive, under two scenarios—280E unchanged, and full rescheduling.

For medical operators, the comparison now looks much like any other midsize company’s. For adult-use operators, it shows how much money leaves the building every year, and how much of it could stay.


Patrick Johnston

By Patrick Johnston, Co-Founder, 3F Captive Services

Patrick Johnston is co-founder of 3F Captive Services, which helps mid-sized businesses form and manage captive insurance companies. He has spent more than twenty years running and investing in businesses: he operated a dairy, has owned S&P Ranch, LLC, a California specialty-crop grower, since 2008, and has been chief executive of AgCentra Capital Management since 2016. He co-founded 3F in 2022 and works with owners in agriculture, cannabis, transportation and logistics, construction, health care, hospitality, and professional services. He holds a B.A. in economics from the University of Washington and an M.B.A. from Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management.

This is sponsored content. It was written by Patrick Johnston of 3F Captive Services and published by HCN in partnership with 3F Captive Services. It is for general information only and is not insurance, tax, or legal advice. Readers should consult their own qualified advisers.

About the Author: HCN News Team

The News Team at Highly Capitalized are some of the most experienced writers in cannabis and psychedelics business & finance. We cover capital markets, finance, branding, marketing and everything important in between. Most of all, we follow the money.

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!